Played with both this past weekend. Using the laser rangefinder with a hand
compass was straightforward and I was confident of the targets. If you have something you can get a good reflection off the distance can be quite decent; one of my landmarks was measured at 1030 meters.
With the radar it was hard to know which part of the shore features were being measured although the general picture was sufficient. So, in good conditions the rangefinder would be my preference.
Here's the wrinkle: at end of day the
fog came in. The rangefinder started having trouble returning distances, and eventually there were no visual landmarks remaining at all. The only remaining options were
GPS position and the radar. (I suppose the
depth sounder also counts.)