Quote:
Originally Posted by foamcows
Was interesting to read the first ten pages and then the last ten pages, going from everyone arguing it will never work to being shown real world numbers indicating it actually can.
Currently starting out our planning process for purchasing a new 40-50 ft cat in the next year or two and trying to figure out what makes more sense... your traditional diesel or the OV servo prop hybrid configuration.
The number that really stands out to me is the distance you can motor on 100 liters of fuel... 325nm ( https://oceanvolt.com/twin-saildrive-10/). What I am struggling to find is what is the expected distance one can cruise on a traditional diesel config with 100 liters of fuel?
At the end of the day, miles per liter is all that matters to me.
If I get more miles per liter with the hybrid system motoring versus a normal diesel system, the decision is made because it only gets better from there with electric anytime I am not motoring around.
|
The OceanVolt system is a series hybrid. As such it will lose 15-25% in range comparted to a direct drive ICE or parallel hybrid using the same prime mover (ICE engine). A series hybrid converts the energy from the ICE to electicity (at a 7-13% penalty) sends that
power over
cables (which will cost in the region of (1%) to the motors which convert it back at 7-13% penalty.
With a direct drive ICE the
power the motor "delivers" depends on where it is measured, at the crankshaft before the
transmission or at the prop after the
transmission and drive seal. The transmission will enact a 2-3% penalty in power and the
shaft seal a bit more.
As a guess, using the same amount a fuel a direct drive system could go 390nm at the same speed. A parallel hybrid might be a bit better. At low maneuvering speeds at each end a parallel hybrid could use the electric drive and shut down the ICE.
The EU did a study of hybrid
marine propulsion (HYMAR) which ultimately concluded parallel was generally the better system for several reasons, significantly better fuel efficiency being one of them. Another technology the Europeans have pursued for decades is controllable
pitch props. The efficiency advantage is significant to them because of the high cost of fuel. In the US where the fuel has tended to be
cheap, a lower cost, low
maintenance fixed prop was the better economic choice.
https://www.boats.com/reviews/all-about-saildrives/
Of note in the OV system, the prime mover is a 10kW ICE. Regardless of how big the prop drivers are, past the first 20nm or so of a long run when the
batteries have been expended, the
boat will only move as fast as 10kW (13hp) can move the
boat. Unless your are using 1-2kW
solar panels which will boost the speed by 1/4kt or so.