I realize that this is a 2 year old thread, but as it still comes up on
Google for those reading it for information. I have four comments on the above. First, if you are using your dink in protected, inland waters, with no strong currents, a
Portland Pudgy is fine. Otherwise, no. It will swamp in rough
water and does not allow for anything but the smallest HP
engine. Second, I have a 14 year old Avon. Has done a good job. Avon is now owned by
Zodiac. Not as good reports. Third, the differences between your top quality hypalon dink is not durability, but
hull and tube design. You see more AB dinks on
bluewater cruisers because they have a higher, roomier bow (better in waves, easier to get on and off, and carrying groceries), arguably more stable, and can accept a larger HP
engine. Fourth, St. Martin in the
Caribbean has the best deals on dinks that I know. I am planning on sailing over the end of this month to pick up a new AB dink that I just ordered.