Cruisers & Sailing Forums (https://www.cruisersforum.com/forums/)
-   Monohull Sailboats (https://www.cruisersforum.com/forums/f47/)
-   -   MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55 (https://www.cruisersforum.com/forums/f47/moody-54-ds-v-s-beneteau-oceanis-55-a-141424.html)

alexxx 17-02-2015 13:11

MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
hello everyone !
i am hesitating between those two monohulls - the new moody 54ds and the new beneteau-oceanis-55.......
for quite some time now my mind has actually been set on buying a catamaran, but the the more i think about it, and the more i'm exploring the monohull option....
I love those two boats above. I haven't sailed them yet, but visited them at numerous boat shows...My plan will be to cruise and circumnavigate...... how do they behave in rough waters? what the their durability, build quality, and sturdiness? how do these boats compare?
thanks for any info you can get me, and your experiences.....

Rohan 17-02-2015 14:58

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
No experience with either (other than walking through on boat shows), but I guess it depends on how you like to use it. Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I assume:

1. The Beneteau 55 will be a little cheaper, but the Moody 54 will be slightly better quality.

2. B55 has a better, wide open cockpit, with all around view. M54 has a better salon with all around view.

3. Due to hard chines and lower center of gravity and lower profile, the B55 will have a smoother ride and sail slightly faster. However, the M54 has a nav station with clear view forward, from which I assume you could pilot the boat in comfort during bad weather.

4. M54 seems to have more dedicated room for storage.

5. The master cabin on the B55 is amazingly well laid out.

6. I like how the Moody DS boats are built like power boats with two levels of accomodations. Like on a catamaran, you can walk from the galley to the cockpit without having to go up steps. However, the design means the 3 cabins are all very close to one another, which also means less privacy.

It's a bit of a toss up. In the long run, I would probably prefer the M54 DS for cruising, but if it were 3 couples aboard, or any large groups of people (for example, if you entertain a lot) I think the B55 would work better.

Orion Jim 17-02-2015 15:39

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
I envy anyone burdened with having to make such a decision. Good luck.

Andy73 17-02-2015 16:54

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jim Walsh (Post 1751853)
I envy anyone burdened with having to make such a decision. Good luck.

:biggrin:

I was going to suggest he buy a 5 year old version of each and I would take whichever one he didn't like off his hands for free :thumb:

Eleuthera 2014 18-02-2015 01:16

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andy73 (Post 1751953)
:biggrin:

I was going to suggest he buy a 5 year old version of each and I would take whichever one he didn't like off his hands for free :thumb:

Neither are particularly good Blue Water boats... if I was looking at those 2, I would have a long sideways glance at Bene 57's... no longer very new but very good value for money. Avoid the dark Blue hulls ...

... or perhaps you have more money than most of us :biggrin:

Good Luck in your quest.

Cherp 18-02-2015 05:44

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
First World dilemma.

chris4911 18-02-2015 08:22

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
I have a new oceanis 48, and am thinking of trading up to the 55. The Hanse 575, is also an option and a beautiful boat. The 55 has so much more room and storage than the 48. Did not go on the Moody in Annapolis, so I can't speak to that. I know the 48 is a good rough sea boat so far. Needs ten knots to move, but really goes in 25

MarkJ 18-02-2015 11:26

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
Whats the price difference between them?

Either would be fine for a curcumnavigation.

ALAIN97133 18-02-2015 11:58

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
2 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by alexxx (Post 1751663)
hello everyone ! i am hesitating between those two monohulls - the new moody 54ds and the new beneteau-oceanis-55....... for quite some time now my mind has actually been set on buying a catamaran, but the the more i think about it, and the more i'm exploring the monohull option.... I love those two boats above. I haven't sailed them yet, but visited them at numerous boat shows...My plan will be to cruise and circumnavigate .... how do they behave in rough waters? what the their durability, build quality, and sturdiness? how do these boats compare? thanks for any info you can get me, and your experiences.....

I would choose the Moody if, tired of the Tropics I'd like to cool down for a while in British Columbia or New Zealand (Inside steering compulsory) ... If I intend to escape winter altogether, I would choose the Beneteau Oceanis 55 that looks more like a summer fun sailboat :)

anacapaisland42 18-02-2015 14:08

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
We were in Puerto Morelos when a 55 foot Beneteau came racing in, all pumps running because pounding and one big heavy slam had blown out the plumbing on one of the forward thru hulls. Probably an older boat, probably not maintained properly, etc.
Take the Moody.
Bill

ArmyDaveNY 18-02-2015 18:48

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
I have never sailed the Oceanis 55 however I have been on one at the boat show a couple of years ago, and a couple of things come to mind. I am six feet tall however the coach roof was extremely tall and I had trouble seeing over it. My then girlfriend was in the low five foot range and couldn't see over at all, so she would not be able to assist with steering under most cases.

This was due to the sole only being a couple of steps down. The hull seemed very flat and more designed as a VERY nice apartment. This flat hull didn't seem like it would be very sea kindly when beating to windward. Additionally, the windows in both the coachroof and the hull were VERY large, again more akin to a waterside apartment than a blue water boat. I wouldn't feel very comfortable going more than a couple of days offshore but depending upon your travel plans, it might be fine for what you are doing.

The Oceanis had the potential for a LOT of stowage. It was kitted out with all sorts of gadgets and electronics but my personal preference would to NOT have some of those things such as in mast furling, etc. simply because there is more to go wrong on an extended cruse. It was however a very airy and spacious vessel. For coastal cruising, I think it would be very comfortable, aside from the excessively tall coach roof. For travels around the world, I wouldn't feel too comfortable with it.

DeepFrz 18-02-2015 19:16

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
alexxx, have you looked at the Garcia Exploration 52?

xsteel 18-02-2015 19:46

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
I know one very nice gentleman who bought the Moody late last year & sailed in the Sydney to Hobart yacht race leaving Sydney on 26-12-2014 in it's 1st race - Trybooking.com - Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race 2014. You could try contacting Royal Brighton Yacht Club in Melbourne Australia, who should be able to put you in contact with Grant Dunoon.

downunder 18-02-2015 19:48

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
Moody looks good here.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_vSLc5JXnU8

Zzmeyer 18-02-2015 21:00

Re: MOODY 54-DS V/S beneteau-OCEANIS 55
 
Love both. Seriously considered oceanis 55 at $760k delivered San Diego with all the toys. I was priced out of moody at $1.1m. Significantly different boats. I went with sense 50 which I think in many ways is similar to moody. Don't know moody quality given built by hanse and not sure why so much more expensive than a hanse 575. I suggest you get one of each.


Sent from my iPad using Cruisers Sailing Forum


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 16:17.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.


ShowCase vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.