While I've never been in Guaymas or
San Carlos, I have many years of experience in
La Paz. The town itself is great. Many great restaurants and shops and bars. Plenty of
parts availability too.
I have always kept my
boat in Marina De La Paz, in fact I'm heading back there in November. The marina is safe and well maintained, with helpful staff. The locker rooms are clean and the docks have
security cameras. The best part is all the liveaboards. It is really a small neighborhood. You will make lots of friends here.
The local islands are simply amazing, with three islands within a couple of hours of the the marina. You can venture farther north and hit a number of additional islands and
anchorages on the peninsula. The
fishing and
diving are amazing, with clear and warm
water most of the year.
If you do relocate down there look me up. M/V Ansedonia in Marina De La Paz.
Cheers, Bill