Tough call. Both are good boats.
The 25' Mac is bigger, light and quick (recently apparently entered into the "sailboat hall of fame or some such...) It can be singlehanded, and parts
seem readily available. Light and fast when properly sailed, no frills. Does it have the pop top canvas
? Motors (and especially ones capable of charging batteries
or running lights) are expensive.
The 22' has an outboard
, and they're not cheap
. They both have trailers (condition?) and sounds like they may both have hull
to be replaced. Check your agent for insurance
costs. They are generally pretty cheap
WHERE ARE YOU GOING TO STORE IT?