I know different places have different rules but . . . .
We were insured through Club
Marine and they had a fistful of rules that we were unable or unwilling to comply with. So we changed our insurer, they had a different set of rules that we didn't like but when we logically challenged them, they capitulated and provided the required cover.
I struggle to see why an insurer would have a problem with a "permanently" anchored vessel that has someone "permanently" living on it. When anyone goes out sailing, their
boat may be left on
anchor for periods of 12 hours or more unattended and there is no problem with
insurance. We routinely leave our boat on
anchor and spend a night with friends/family who live in that area. It's discussing this sort of logic with the
broker that removes illogical barriers.
Another thing - I have always been under the impression that the "final" underwriter in marine
insurance is always Lloyds, irrespective of the local provider?
And about the chicken/egg thing. Our local marina insists on proof of insurance before entering the marina for any reason. A few years ago we had friends sail into our area on holiday and they were required to send such proof to the marina before going into the fuelling point to load
diesel. As a result of that, we now keep a stored image of our insurance cover on a phone/tablet. When you think of it, an uninsured visiting boat loading
fuel represents a significant risk for a marina.