After watching others "experiment" successfully with Poliglow, we did our boat four years ago. In short, where we did the job correctly it is beautiful and holds up well. I get many compliments on how beautiful the
hull shines.
The boat is in fresh
water, out of the
water six months per year.
White gelcoat with blue boot stripe.
Successful application of Poliglow is, unfortunately like everything else in life, all in the preparation.
We bought the kit, and started with the included cleaner/ stripper. After three cleanings there was still a film of wax. So we used comet on the entire
hull then cleansed with Simple Green. 2 people, 8 hours, two days = 32 man hours to clean the hull.
Applying it is stupid simple and one coat takes less than an hour.
Poliglow instructions warn that the first coat will look awful, and that's true. It scared the bejesus out of me. We did another four coats for a total of five coats, each one looking better. Total time four hours.
So impressed with the hull, I (yes, my decision) decided to do the toerail and
cabin sides. I did a half-assed
cleaning, which still took three hours. This was a big mistake, because when done I could see previously hidden dirt and way underneath. And within a year it had yellowed and started flaking. I let it go for the next three years to see what would happen, and it continued to wear off to about 50%. Last month I put two coats over the old stuff (and trapped dirt) as an
experiment. I anticipate that next year I'll have to strip it all off and do it properly.
Each Fall it takes about 2.5 hours to properly clean the hull (figure have to do that with wax anyway) and maybe 40 minutes to apply one coat of Poliglow. Previously, waxing in Fall would take close to 3 hours, and waxing in Spring (big mistake) closer to 8 hours. I don't know how the Poliglow would differ if done in Spring when it's cold and damp.
Areas that have heavy runoff will stain, but this will clean off rather easily. Areas that experience abrasion (fenders rolling back and forth) get the dirt ground in. This year for the first time it was so bad I had to scrub down to the gelcoat and re-apply the Poliglow. No big deal; a bit more
work than wax
repair, but still only a 30 minute job.
Powerboat wake popped my fenders and put the hull into the
dock pretty hard, chewing through the Poliglow. This too was a fix-it job, scrubbing off the Poliglow (which, by the way, took the mark instead of the gelcoat) and re-apply, which was done in that same 30 minute window.
We did not do the
cockpit because it's such a high wear area, and I'm glad I stuck to wax there. I believe keeping up with 100% coverage of Poliglow in the
cockpit would take far more time than pulling out the 3M restorer wax.
I recently cleaned and waxed (3M Restorer) my new-to-me 1967 Sunfish. The oxidation wasn't too bad, but the 3M really disappointed me- it didn't look much different than before. In hindsight, I should have used Poliglow. I've seen oxidized hulls done with Poliglow, and the results are a magnitude better than wax.
So that's the long and short of my experience with Poliglow. It is ALL in the preparation! And, at least in my case, the Poliglow cleaner didn't do the job, so keep that in mind.