I am trying to replace the prop for my 2005 Johnson 9.9
2 stroke outboard that I use on an older 9ft, soft bottom
Avon inflatable. I find what I need online but I have to choose a pitch

I have no idea, the
current prop is original and I don't
recall anyone discussing
pitch when we bought it, no markings to be found, and although we have a cheapie tachometer I don't think we would get helpful info from this chipped, cruddy old prop. So, I know it's a 9 1/2"
3 blade, but should the
pitch be 7" 8" 9" 10"?
I don't need performance/speed (ha ha). Just average speed/oomph for tooling around. Any ideas? I was thinking of using 8" pitch but that is just a guess.