Quote:
Originally Posted by Shenan
what is in that picture ?
|
The
outremer where
mast broke through
deck, made it only from La Grande Motte till Gran Canaria. Was long in Arrecife/Lanzarote as it got inspected by court
surveyor. Now settled and clear production defect. One of 3 that are known to have this issue.[/QUOTE]
OK, still not true !
This
boat is a 55', not a 45', and you definitly twist reality.
Isolated case (I will detail), absolutely no "3 identified cases", and no court case under way. Give more details, or stop repeating these !
On the 55', during random quality controls on the first
boats, we identified a risk in a carbon post built by a subcontractant, under supposely very high building stds. There were 2 spots with lamination issues, probably within
safety margin, but impossible to prove.
We inspected all
boats with these posts (6), and decided to replace 2 which were not within quality acceptance (probably strong enough, but don't want to take the risk).
On this
boat, this was done in
Canaries, technicians had to fly there, but were not allowed to board the plane with the products they need to use to install it. They used local products which were supposely same quality, but we know they were not.
After new post was laminated,
mast post was slipping after the first test sail in
Canaries. Back to port, with a damaged coachroof obviously.
Of course, it will be fixed with a new coachroof.
But no court case, just delayed projects for the owner !
Again, isolated case, all boats have proved carbon posts, 55's sailed a total of 450 000 nm alltogether far without issues.[/QUOTE]
Sorry what you state is wrong, the
outremer was on the pontoon next to mine for several month. I know the court surveyour from
Germany very well as he was also in parallel supervising the
repairs on my cat for AXA
insurance.
That was a court case with 3 years duration and clear production issue where the mast broke through completely. Now the whole structure was done new and a complete new roof was mounted after it was finally settled. Appoval of completed
repair was done at 9.2.24 in marina puerto calero.