L&N are of course correct, a lighter
boat will outperform a heavier one, but a
boat designed to be commodious and comfortable will always be more comfortable than one designed for speed. It's all a compromise. We test sailed a
Catana 50 and an
Outremer 49 within 24 hours of each other at their yards in
France in similar conditions (light airs). The
Outremer was undoubtedly the slightly quicker boat. We bought a
Catana. Doesn't make it a wrong decision or a bad boat, it meant that was the right boat for us.
It depends why you are
buying one. We have now lived on ours for 4 months in great comfort and we didn't want to compromise too much on that comfort. The boat
sails exceptionally well and we didn't want to compromise too much on that performance.
We could have bought an Outremer or a
Lagoon for less
money, but wanted performance AND luxury so we paid the extra and bought a Catana. No boat is right or wrong, it's just different strokes for different folks.