Ok, I'll play.
We've lived on Copernicus, a Spencer 42 for 28 years. 18 years ago for a laugh and something to do we built a custom pre-peg carbon fibre free standing mast. It was designed by Eric Sponberg and he also designed a nifty carbon fibre spade
rudder for the boat but thats another story.
Having the opportunity to sail the same boat with two different kind of rigs over a longish period of time has given us some cool insights to the good and bad of both.
Pluses and minuses of the unstayed compared to the old stayed rig on Copernicus
Pluses,
Faster, way faster, on all points of sail, especially in light airs.
Easier to handle despite having more sail area.
Sailing with just the main up is still pretty fast.
Quiet, no high pitched screeching in high winds.
On
offshore passages reefing downwind is easier for crew to
single hand.
Fewer
single point failure scenarios.
Deeper DW angles without giving away too much boat speed.
Handier and more predictable in tight quarters.
A slight improvement in windward ability.
Having to unlearn a lot of ingrained stayed rig sailing knowledge/thinking.
Tons more fun to day sail.
Carey can and does sail the boat by herself with little effort.
Serious geeking out on
Dyneema splices and the like. Of course the same can be done with a stayed rig so call that a wash.
Did I mention quiet?
Minuses
Getting proper, well shaped set of
sails took
work
Halyards that in our case need to be low stretch line.
One off rig means most of the
hardware is custom (read expensive)
Having to beef up the gooseneck,
deck gear, vang, mainsheet blocks and such.
Lightning now scares the crap out of me.
Having to unlearn a lot of ingrained stayed rig sailing knowledge/thinking.
Thats about it, me thinks,
Cheers,
Bryan
PS. In the bow on shot I'm sailing singlehanded in
La Paz harbour in 20 knots of
wind and in my excitment had forgotten to crank up on the jib
halyard, hence the uncharactaristic jibstay sag. Thats my story and I'm sticking to it.
More photos and vids here.
The Boat - oliveoyl