Originally Posted by SwissMocha
It's true, no constant. However, last year when I cruised in Greece
, I had two rocky nights in two weeks. Do I remember the quiet nights? No sir
For the roll, I have not so much experience myself. But here is a Youtube link I found on the Website of Bobby Schenk.
But everything is a compromise and the mono people will tell us, that a multihull
will slap, which might for some be more annoying than the rolling...
Apart from aesthetics, the choice for me depends very much on the intended use. And this is really the core
of the issue. Right now I charter
use and the choice for that is usually monos, because it's much cheaper and it's about sailing.
When I'm done working I plan to buy a boat
and go cruising. And when I'm cruising and living aboard
it's not so much about sailing and/or how the boat
looks, but much more about staying at anchorages
or in marinas
and how comfortable I am doing so. Okey, it's still about looks
and in the end, it's all purely emotional
There is no doubt that downwind in what regards roll a cat rolls less. Modern beamy boats with all beam brought back (like the Sense) do a lot better then the monohulls on that movie
even if not as well as a cat. But the movie
only shows downwind sailing and upwind is not only a question of the water
slapping on the hulls but also having two hulls hitting the same wave at slightly different times.
I agree that is a question of personal taste and therefore this thread has not much sense. Since the OP talks about a comparison value for money
stability and comfort he only have to charter
for a week or so Beneteau
Sense and a cat with about the same price
, for instance a Lagoon
39 and a Beneteau
Sense 46, that cost about the same and take his own conclusions.
Bobby Schenkn is a good example in what regards preferences and knowledge: He sailed many time a monohull
, changed for a multihull
, sailed it extensively and changed again his preferences for a monohull
. I bet he sees advantages and disadvantages in each design.