This would be a great question for the
Catalina owners group @ catalina36.org
Our 36 is a later model but I suspect the
keel bolts, washers, ect. are the same.
The
keel bolts are all the same size 3/4” except the front that is slightly smaller. The washers are 1 &11/16” diameter and approximately 1/8” to 3/16” thick with a lock washer. The nut and washers are marked 316, referring to the stainless grade.
I’d consider going to
Catalina for a replacement or possibly Catalina Direct.
Wonder why yours has been removed and best of luck with the
repair.