Impossible to truly say would be my thoughts. What is important to some is irrelevant to others. Give me a thread full of technical jabber and how to fix things, and i will glaze over and move on. Yes, they are fantastic and informative, but i will search for them if and when i need them.
I come on this forum every day, practically, to see what the other folks who enjoy the cruising lifestyle, doing it or not, are talking about and to converse about boats, sailing and anything else, hopefully with a bit of fun in it. That is the key word for me, fun. Give me a thread where the wit is flying around, or even just plain silly and I am in heaven. Someone mentioned the "Bucket" thread earlier in this one and that was just brilliant, to me. Some fine writing with some hilarious comments, made my week or so on here that one.
Give me fun and laughter, that is what is important in my mind and life, and I am aware that some folks do not come on here for that at all, but there has to be room for it surely.
The "Most Important' is as variable as the "best boat" and which bucket you prefer.
Thanks to everyone on here that has given me those laughs and smiles anyway.