B,
You have a relatively heavy
boat for 32 feet. Pulling an all chain
rode without a windlass is a workout in good conditions, and a struggle when things deteriorate. I have a 34'
boat, dry weight 11,800 with no windlass. When in
cruise mode, we weigh over 13,000 lbs. My original setup was 35 feet of 5/16 chain and 250' of 5/8
rode with a 35 lb
CQR as my primary anchor. I found after sitting through some 50-knot blows that I needed a heavier chain. Today, I have 40 feet of 3/8" chain with 250 feet of rode. I sleep more securely now and still do not have an unbalanced boat with too much weight in the bow. I use a pair of rubber
work gloves when I pull the hook which gives me a secure grip on the chain--especially when muddy. I do not use a chain stopper but rather my bow cleat when hauling the rode if I need to take a rest. I do not know the specifics of your cruising ground but, as a general comment, I would say if you are strong, in good physical shape and can pull the hook quickly, you should be able to operate without a windlass for many years. We have sailed 18,000 miles without a windlass in bottoms and conditions good and bad and the only serious problem we had was when we set two hooks Bahamian Style and had one hook wrap our
keel during a
wind shift that exposed us to building winds and a questionable lee shore. So, try it for awhile(pulling your hook by hand) in all
weather and bottom conditions and you'll soon have your answer in regards to a windlass. Good luck and safe sailing.