I'm not personally familiar with either sail source. But I would say this, new
sails are or can be a real pleasure. So if you can afford the new one, from a source you've previously satisfied, why not do it? None of us knows how our future plays out in advance. In general, it's easy to say "like new", but it isn't new, and dacron
sails are never very good very long, except for light or small
boats, neither of which category your Nauticat 44 is in.
If not, then perhaps a brief sail to
Florida to have a look at it, or a train or bus ride?
Ann