Welcome aboard CF, akny although I note you came aboard some time ago but thanks for
posting now
.
I can't help directly so this is more of a bump for your question however allow me to suggest to keep trying to remove the old prop.
Use plenty of heat, a good puller and two hammers. Get it hot, really hot, apply plenty of tension with the puller and smack both sides of the boss with the hammers simultaneously.
Keep going until it pops off, i.e. more heat and heavier hammer blows.