Quote:
Originally Posted by belizesailor
Yeah, 101 should not be delivered on a 44' cat, in fact that goes against ASA specifications for 101. Unfortunately, its a fairly common practice because for charter companies its all about booking the charter boats.
When I ran a school, I kept a couple of small boats on hand just for the hands on skills of 101. As should any sailing school that offers 101.
|
I think this is a very good point.
I think there are sailing skills and experiences (of sensations) that one can feel in a
small boat (up to about 30') that one cannot feel on a large
catamaran.
The ASA (now USSailing) school that I went to in
San Francisco, had Colgate 26 boats for the first
classes. This is an open
boat, 26 feet long, and very responsive
keel boat. It is a tiller boat. It provides very fast feedback and good control. It is small enough that a person can manage the
helm and the sheet at the same time.
It also responded to the
wind and waves, giving one a sense of what was working and not working.
It also gave the
newbie sailor (I was not one at the time) a lot of confidence in boat sailing and handling (e.g.
Docking, heave to, etc.).
Later, the
classes moved up to 36 foot and even larger 42 foot boats.
I think this progression is very sensible, even if someone wants to later own a large cat, but has no prior sailing experience where they had to control the boat (not just sitting as a guest).
I just recently finished a 640nm voyage on a 52 foot cat. IF I were a
newbie, I would not want to start
learning about sailing on a large cat, as a newbie (someone without any sailing experience at the helm). I think it is better to learn on smaller boats, then progress up to larger as your skills and confidence merit.
____________
That said, if I did have some previous sailing experience, and wanted to get experience on a larger boat, to augment my experience on smaller boats, I think the
liveaboard option is a good one. That
service, or lessons or
liveaboard classes provided by such folks as LTD Sailing in
Grenada, would be something I would seriously consider.