Cruisers & Sailing Forums (http://www.cruisersforum.com/forums/)
-   Deck hardware: Rigging, Sails & Hoisting (http://www.cruisersforum.com/forums/f116/)
-   -   304 vs 316 for Mast Step Fasteners (http://www.cruisersforum.com/forums/f116/304-vs-316-for-mast-step-fasteners-76137.html)

svtatoosh 03-02-2012 12:50

304 vs 316 for Mast Step Fasteners
 
Hi Folks,

I'm installing Seadog folding aluminum mast steps on an aluminum mast with 1/4" ss machine screws. With the 316 grade, it's about $700 for 70, so I'm seriously looking @ going with 304. Any big liability?

Thanks!

Tom
Astoria

s/v Jedi 03-02-2012 13:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by svtatoosh
Hi Folks,

I'm installing Seadog folding aluminum mast steps on an aluminum mast with 1/4" ss machine screws. With the 316 grade, it's about $700 for 70, so I'm seriously looking @ going with 304. Any big liability?

Thanks!

Tom
Astoria

What exactly are you paying per fastener?! Not $10.- each I hope?

ciao!
Nick

svtatoosh 03-02-2012 13:30

Re: 304 vs 316 for mast step fasteners
 
Fisheries in Seattle 1/4 - 20 x 3/4 are $11.73 each.

Boracay 03-02-2012 13:31

Re: 304 vs 316 for mast step fasteners
 
I did a quick search and McMaster Carr have 1/4" 316 in 1" (a guess) for $4.19 for a pack of 10.

Your instructions should make it very clear exactly how the step should be installed. With such a critical item I'd follow them to the letter, or get any changes approved by the manufacturer.

svtatoosh 03-02-2012 13:32

Re: 304 vs 316 for mast step fasteners
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Boracay (Post 878880)
I did a quick search and McMaster Carr have 1/4" 316 in 1" (a guess) for $4.19 for a pack of 10.

Your instructions should make it very clear exactly how the step should be installed. With such a critical item I'd follow them to the letter, or get any changes approved by the manufacturer.


Maybe I'm missing the package price...wasn't listed. Thanks.

s/v Jedi 03-02-2012 13:34

Quote:

Originally Posted by svtatoosh
Fisheries in Seattle 1/4 - 20 x 3/4 are $11.73 each.

I think that will be or 25 of them. Should be less than $0.50 each. If not, they are cheating you...

ciao!
Nick.

Cotemar 03-02-2012 14:28

Re: 304 vs 316 for mast step fasteners
 
1 Attachment(s)
svtatoosh,

If its these Sea Dog Folding Mast Steps.
It says to use #10 Flat Head

Sea Dog Folding Mast Step

Also make sure you use Tef-Gel on all the screws or the threads will bond to the aluminum in just a few years

Ultra Safety Systems TG25 Ultra Tef Gel

sailorboy1 03-02-2012 14:43

Re: 304 vs 316 for mast step fasteners
 
I feel 304 is fine for that application out in the open air, but ony if the price is really a lot more because when in doubt do it "right"

Jimbo485 03-02-2012 15:12

Re: 304 vs 316 for mast step fasteners
 
Why wouldnīt you use aluminium when joining two pieces together (mast and step)???

I used aluminium rivets to attach my mast steps to the mast. I had enough stainlesss rivets to use, but I didnīt want the disimilar metals joining themselves together.

Looks fine so far, I havenīt fallen yet, so what is wrong with the logic of aluminium fasteners for aluminium pieces?

ReMetau 03-02-2012 15:59

Re: 304 vs 316 for mast step fasteners
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jimbo485 (Post 878942)
Why wouldnīt you use aluminium when joining two pieces together (mast and step)???

I used aluminium rivets to attach my mast steps to the mast. I had enough stainlesss rivets to use, but I didnīt want the disimilar metals joining themselves together.

Looks fine so far, I havenīt fallen yet, so what is wrong with the logic of aluminium fasteners for aluminium pieces?


I used aluminum rivets on my glass steps. It was five rivets per step, and I haven't seen any issues yet. I feel very comfortable climbing up.

Jimbo485 03-02-2012 16:06

Re: 304 vs 316 for mast step fasteners
 
Yes, Remetau. I think the question was incorrectly worded.

It should have said, "Should I use dissimilar metals to connect an important piece of equipment to the mast - a piece of equipment which helps me avoid extreme deceleration trauma in the event of its failure?"

And the answer would be ,"Avoid dissimilar metals like the plague, especially when the deceleration trauma has the potential to kill you!"

Cotemar 03-02-2012 16:17

Re: 304 vs 316 for mast step fasteners
 
2 Attachment(s)
I agree with using aluminum rivits on the aluminum mast.
Much easyer to install also.
I installed mine with aluminum rivits.

sabray 03-02-2012 16:22

Usually stainless fasteners bond so that the will not be able to be removed. Never gave I seen a ss fastener fail in a mast because of dissimilarity. Hence use teff gel or lancote. Either way is probably fine. Aluminum does not shear load well. With 5 rivets done properly there is probably enough surface si it's okay. Also there are
Different grades of blind rivets. Make sure you use the right spec. There was another thread about that I can't remember the details. also check Jamestown distributors.

barnakiel 03-02-2012 16:28

Re: 304 vs 316 for mast step fasteners
 
What happens if you use monel ones?

I think (?) most of our mast hardware is attached with monel.

b.

sailorboy1 03-02-2012 16:38

Re: 304 vs 316 for mast step fasteners
 
I still like the 304SS with the proper protection installation care taken. I just don't feel as comfortable with aluminum. And I doubt I would be too worried if in a mast step app I would care if it bonded as I wouldn't on ever wanting to take it apart as a routine matter.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 05:18.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.


ShowCase vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.