Cruisers & Sailing Forums (
-   Health, Safety & Related Gear (
-   -   Methane Accumulation (

syblackwell 02-10-2015 09:24

Methane Accumulation
We live aboard. We have a head that burps gas a few times a week. We use a powerful tank bubbler for 20 minutes every hour on a timer so I think this is coming from residual in the lines and Electrosan. However, last week our bilge alarm went off (we could not figure out what was wrong and it was very periodic, so we have had to turn it off) The last couple of days we have actually detected a gaseous smell. Is it possible for methane from a head to accumulate over time in such concentration it is dangerous from an explosive perspective? We are on a catamaran with bunks up high in a well ventilated cabin so we have not been as concerned with breathability .. although at this point we are beginning to get so.

Today we are going to use evacuation fans on deck with hoses to the bilges to vent the boat. We will also be turning the alarm back on and not staying on board if it persists ... but we still wonder if methane could cause this.

tbodine88 02-10-2015 09:47

Re: Methane Accumulation
No, Methane is lighter than air , however hydrogen sulfide is not and could collect in the bilge. Hydrogen sulfide is deadly so you plan of action is a good one.

Hydra 02-10-2015 12:50

Re: Methane Accumulation
Methane has no odor. Hydrogen sulfide has (rotten eggs) and, in addition to being deadly to breath and heavier than air, is explosive in the right concentration.


farm sail 02-10-2015 12:59

Re: Methane Accumulation
What sort of bilge alarm Do you have that is going off most alarms are only able to detect certain things What is yours designed to detect That might narrow down what the problem is

thinwater 02-10-2015 13:34

Re: Methane Accumulation
A. Bilge alarms (I assume you mean a propane gas detector) are sensitive to moisture. It could be false.
B. It is FAR more likely to be a propane issue. Leak test the system.

As people have stated, methane rises; collecting enough from a rare toilet burp is impossible. Yes, H2S can be toxic, but the smell would be strong enough to make the boat completely unlivable first. People seldom die from farts, and that is what you are questioning.

Check the propane system first, just to be certain. Check the sensor and then turn it back on. Then find out why the head is bubbling. By far the most likely problem is a blocked holding tank vent. What else would supply the pressure to push the gas through the head? The fact that you have a bubbler only increase the required gas flow through the vent. It also greatly reduces the amount of methane in the gas.

colemj 02-10-2015 13:43

Re: Methane Accumulation

Originally Posted by thinwater (Post 1928276)
People seldom die from farts

Not to hear my wife tell itů :whistling:


Wotname 02-10-2015 14:31

Re: Methane Accumulation
A cautionary note on the effects of Hydrogen sulphide.

In small concentrations it has a very distinct smell (rotten eggs) but in increasing concentrations one quickly losses the ability to smell it. In effect, your nose is overloaded and you loose this "early warning" sense.

The upshot of this is if you smell Hydrogen sulphide and then for no apparent reason, the smell disappears, get out of the area fast.

GordMay 03-10-2015 03:44

Re: Methane Accumulation
Greetings and welcome aboard the CF, syblackwell.

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 08:28.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.

ShowCase vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.