Cruisers & Sailing Forums (http://www.cruisersforum.com/forums/)
-   Powered Boats (http://www.cruisersforum.com/forums/f109/)
-   -   I Learned Something Today! (http://www.cruisersforum.com/forums/f109/i-learned-something-today-106237.html)

GalaxyGirl 23-06-2013 19:18

I Learned Something Today!
 
It's true. The more boats that you walk on, the more you will learn. Today I learned that I do not want a bend over engine room. They are hot and cramped. There is no space to do anything. I don't even understand how folks access the different equipment. If something breaks, you have to rip out other systems to get to it? That's insane.

Stand-up engine rooms are definitely the way to go.

Sandero 23-06-2013 19:22

Re: I learned something today!
 
This is a good example of how experience is a great teacher... and there are so many little things to learn like the type of engine room config that you simply have to get on and sail lots of boats before committing.

Suijin 23-06-2013 19:24

Re: I learned something today!
 
I'm six foot one, 200 lbs. and I access my engine room through a door the size of a kitchen cabinet door, behind the companionway stairs. And the floor is the hull, so it's tilted. And the "headroom" is about 4.5". I stare at the door every time I have to go in and mutter "Can't t his wait?". Even checking the oil is a job for a contortionist.

I'm single by the way, and looking. If you are slight and under 5'2", mechanically inclined give me a shout.

Rakuflames 23-06-2013 19:33

Re: I learned something today!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Suijin (Post 1268362)
I'm six foot one, 200 lbs. and I access my engine room through a door the size of a kitchen cabinet door, behind the companionway stairs. And the floor is the hull, so it's tilted. And the "headroom" is about 4.5". I stare at the door every time I have to go in and mutter "Can't t his wait?". Even checking the oil is a job for a contortionist.

I'm single by the way, and looking. If you are slight and under 5'2", mechanically inclined give me a shout.



One of the most liberating things about my new engine is the location to check and change the oil, which no longer requires a contortionist. In addition, on the old engine you had to remove the water pump to change the impeller. No more!

Teknav 23-06-2013 20:35

Re: I Learned Something Today!
 
Hiya Suijin! You're looking for a diesel mechanic mate; not a wife! What a goof! :whistling: :D

Mauritz
Going to behave now!

bobconnie 23-06-2013 20:57

Re: I Learned Something Today!
 
:thumb:G Girl, I still think you should be looking at some of the steel boats bilt in Seattle WA. The are from 50 ft up with large engine rooms and most times they have long range tankage. In the 55 to 70 ft size you should find everything you might wish from state rooms to room to work below ! Just a thought

Rakuflames 23-06-2013 21:07

Re: I Learned Something Today!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bobconnie (Post 1268433)
:thumb:G Girl, I still think you should be looking at some of the steel boats bilt in Seattle WA. The are from 50 ft up with large engine rooms and most times they have long range tankage. In the 55 to 70 ft size you should find everything you might wish from state rooms to room to work below ! Just a thought



I have a friend with a 44' Islander and you can walk around his engine like it was a blender on the kitchen counter or something. With the right boat you don't have to go "huge."

Strait Shooter 23-06-2013 21:11

Re: I Learned Something Today!
 
I wish I had a walk in engine room......mines more of a crawl in engine room. Everything's accessible, but ya still gotta crawl in.

roverhi 23-06-2013 22:44

Re: I Learned Something Today!
 
Mines very accessible sides, top, front, even the back. Should say that's the case for now. When I put the galley and counter back in it's back to the black hole.

ranger42c 24-06-2013 05:59

Re: I Learned Something Today!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GalaxyGirl (Post 1268355)
It's true. The more boats that you walk on, the more you will learn. Today I learned that I do not want a bend over engine room. They are hot and cramped. There is no space to do anything. I don't even understand how folks access the different equipment. If something breaks, you have to rip out other systems to get to it? That's insane.

Stand-up engine rooms are definitely the way to go.


:)

You can also extend that thinking to AROUND, not just up and down :)

Consider that many engines in a twin-screw arrangement have service components on both inboard and outboard sides. Usually oil and fuel filters are remounted inboard if necessary, but anodes (zincs) and so forth... not so much... so access to the outboard sides of engines can be a factor too.

And then there's the generator(s). And the AC pumps. Et cetera....

Sometimes a low engine room can be nicely supplemented by removable hatches above, although I suspect that's less likely in the range of boats you're shopping.

-Chris

GalaxyGirl 24-06-2013 08:55

Re: I Learned Something Today!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bobconnie (Post 1268433)
:thumb:G Girl, I still think you should be looking at some of the steel boats bilt in Seattle WA. The are from 50 ft up with large engine rooms and most times they have long range tankage. In the 55 to 70 ft size you should find everything you might wish from state rooms to room to work below ! Just a thought

Can you post a link for me so I can take a look? Ya know I'm wide open :)

defever 24-06-2013 15:59

Re: I Learned Something Today!
 
Boat size isn't an issue if the boat is well thought out. .our defever 41 is easy to work on..lift the 3 hatches in the saon and you have easy access to engine/tranny/gen set/batteries and all the plumbing stuff..art defever IS THE MAN!!

GalaxyGirl 24-06-2013 16:55

Re: I Learned Something Today!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by defever (Post 1269138)
Boat size isn't an issue if the boat is well thought out. .our defever 41 is easy to work on..lift the 3 hatches in the saon and you have easy access to engine/tranny/gen set/batteries and all the plumbing stuff..art defever IS THE MAN!!

I would like to take a look at that kind of set-up. Sounds interesting. The boat that I looked at had one way in, and one way out. It was very tight and I couldn't see a way to access the equipment. It was really clostrophobic. The owner was a small person and says he works down there all the time. I would have to give my kids Diesel engine classes, cuz at 5' 9", I'm not fitting in there.

markpierce 24-06-2013 17:04

Re: I Learned Something Today!
 
Through hatches in the pilothouse floor, I'm able to climb in the engine compartment and sit down. There's no crawling.

http://www.cruisersforum.com/attachm...8abd9b2916.jpg

On each side of the engine, there is a battery box for a seat.

charliehows 24-06-2013 17:05

Re: I Learned Something Today!
 
take up yoga (works for me) or...get a bigger boat


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 02:39.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.


ShowCase vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.