Well, if it wasn't a MARPOL violation. And of course, you've got that trash plan sticker down in the galley
I figure that if my "trash" would be eagerly awaited as dinner by the next critter, that's perfect recycling. So if it will not aesthetically impact anyone, one might consider tearing it into coin-sized pieces and feeding the critters, yes.
Trash? Or crab bait? Sometimes it is so hard to tell.
Spare ribs BBQ on the beach? Toss the bare ribs up in the air, watch the seagulls FIGHT to get them. There's even a use for flying rats, who knew non-compostable trash was considered good eating too?