The Perfect Storm example is also not as simple as suggested
When the CG arrived, the Satori had been knocked down twice. Their
sails were so damaged that they had to
motor - and a Westsail 32 does not
motor well in good conditions. The life raft had been
lost overboard. Only the captain was experienced
offshore and he had no help. The two
women crew were too panicked to help operate the boat. Look at the pictures below.
The CG had received a Mayday. There's dispute as to whether the Mayday was authorized by the owner but that's doesn't make the Mayday invalid. The moment a Mayday is issued, the "voyage" is over. It is a call to save lives with no further regard for the vessel or cargo. If you want to save your boat - call PAN.
The vessel was CG documented and the owner held a CG issued captain's
license. The owner was not required to have these to operate the boat. Since the CG issued these, they are fully in their rights to revoke them. The owner says he followed the CG instructions to abandon partly because he did not want to lose his CG Captain's
license.
Cape Hatteras is a very dangerous place in late October. Storms come out of nowhere. Many more ships and lives have been
lost in Northeasters in those waters than hurricanes. Satori was only 50 miles out of Portsmouth VA when he received a NOAH
forecast for a Northeaster with 30
knot winds. He had time and a fair
wind to turn and run back to Portsmouth.
While not intentional, that bad
weather decision became part of the tragic string of
events that led to the death of a CG swimmer and possibly the failure to reach the crew of the Andrea Gail in time. I'd have some trouble sleeping at night.