Claim Yourself as a Liveaboard? - & Tax Question

grunzster · 22-06-2009, 12:39

I've always heard, from various different forums that if you have a loan on your boat, you don't need to tell the bank your living aboard...unless they have clause against liveaboards, in which case you should have found a different lender in the first place.

But that you should always tell your insurance, because if they find out, you could have all kinds of problems as severe as losing your insurance or being denied a claim.

Then on my trip North I ran into someone who gave me a completely different story. He basically told me that the insurance companies kind of define liveaboards as bums with nowhere else to go, and claiming youself as a live abaord would mean a huge increase in your premium, which I've never heard before. He went on to say if you're living aboard by choice, as in you have friends/family in the area where you can go or enough money to buy rent someplace on land, then technically you're not a liveaboard. Also that when you start cruising you should claim yourself as an extended cruiser, not a liveaboard, because that will also make a difference in how your insurance company charges you.

Sounded like a bunch of semantics BS to me, also he seemed to really base this whole theory on FL, which in general really seems to have it out for boaters these day, but I'm not in FL. My policy costs about 1/3 what it would if I ws in FL, so even if it was to go up a little, I doubt it would be that much.

So, is there any shred of truth to this, or should I be on the phone with my insurance ASAP?

Also, I was thinking, even if what this guy said is true. The tiny little bit my insurance may go up, may be offset by potential tax breaks by claiming the boat as a primary residence...especially being that I have a mortgage on it.

Which brings me to question #2. When tax time comes, for all you TurboTax users out there, do I claim the boat the same as a house? AKA: the screen where it asks "Any major life changes this year, for example bought a home?" do I click yes, and go through that whole process that same as if it was a house.

Cheechako · 22-06-2009, 13:23

I would say nothing unless they ask for the info. I dont see why you are obligated to give info you are not asked for. Many will ask I imagine. On the other hand, dont lie either for sure. Interestingly, in the mid 80's when I sailed to Mexico from the Pac Northwest, the insurance company I was with offerred insurance that covered "inland waters and within 75 miles of the coast". Therefore I was insured all the way down the rough Pacific Coast (the "graveyard of the pacific") until I exited the US! This was standard cheap insurance like sold for ski boats etc... I'm sure that has changed! The insurance game seems to be very vague at times, I guess they figure they have more money for lawyers than the buyer does! My current auto insurance company asks for the anticipated driving mileage on each vehicle. For reasons I dont need to go into here, I have traded vehicles a lot in the last couple of years. In doing so, I have changed which cars I drive to work etc. I have received 3 different answers from them about when I can change the predicted mileage. Once they said only at renewal time (May every year), then at renewal time they said, only at the year anniversary of insuring that particular auto, (Both these times I wanted to reduce my predicted mileage), Once when I said I wanted to raise it, they did it right then! (more money for them) It's a real racket....

grunzster · 22-06-2009, 14:06

Well the bank made me sign a no charter affidavit, but not one for living aboard, and my insurance didn't ask anything about living aboard either. So as of now, I'm not lying to either, just not providing additional info that wasn't asked for.

I never really thought of this before, but with a vessel of over a certain size, that has a galley, head, and berth...wouldn't they kind of assume that you're going to be living aboard at least part time? At least maybe weekends for example.

**Hud3** · 22-06-2009, 14:24

When I recently renewed my T.L. Dallas insurance policy, one of the questions on the renewal questionnaire was, "Is this boat your full-time residence?" I can only assume that the policy premium would be affected one way or the other by the answer to that question, but I'm not sure how. Insurers like it when your house is occupied full time. Maybe they feel the same way about boats???

Quote:

Originally Posted by grunzster

...Which brings me to question #2. When tax time comes, for all you TurboTax users out there, do I claim the boat the same as a house? AKA: the screen where it asks "Any major life changes this year, for example bought a home?" do I click yes, and go through that whole process that same as if it was a house.

You can definitely claim a deduction for loan interest paid on a boat that qualifies as a "second home". It just has to have a head and the ability to cook food, as I recall, i.e., it needs to be "livable".

Bash · 22-06-2009, 15:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hud3

When I recently renewed my T.L. Dallas insurance policy, one of the questions on the renewal questionnaire was, "Is this boat your full-time residence?" I can only assume that the policy premium would be affected one way or the other by the answer to that question, but I'm not sure how.

It's possible to buy liveaboard policies that cover you off the premises much the same way that a homeowner's policy does. I have a liveaboard policy that protects me against liability claims when I'm off the boat, and provides for additional living expenses if the boat becomes uninhabitable, and covers theft of personal items on and off the boat. For example, if you break into someone's car and rip off the golf clubs, most people would be covered under their homeowner's policy. Steal my golf clubs and I'm covered under my liveaboard policy.

Back to Hud's question, my guess is that they ask the question on the renewal questionaire so that they could sell you more insurance if you were a liveaboard.

grunzster · 23-06-2009, 12:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bash

It's possible to buy liveaboard policies that cover you off the premises much the same way that a homeowner's policy does. I have a liveaboard policy that protects me against liability claims when I'm off the boat, and provides for additional living expenses if the boat becomes uninhabitable, and covers theft of personal items on and off the boat. For example, if you break into someone's car and rip off the golf clubs, most people would be covered under their homeowner's policy. Steal my golf clubs and I'm covered under my liveaboard policy.

Actually you can get this coverage under any policy. I already have it, although there is a limit. Maybe with a live aboard policy there's a higher limit or none?

But you shouldn't really need that much coverage. Isn't part of living aboard, getting rid of all those expensive dirt dweller toys.

Really, my bike and laptop are by far the most expensive things I need the coverage on. Well and cameras and dive gear, but that's all covered under my dive insurance.

grunzster · 23-06-2009, 12:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hud3

You can definitely claim a deduction for loan interest paid on a boat that qualifies as a "second home". It just has to have a head and the ability to cook food, as I recall, i.e., it needs to be "livable".

I don't own a house, so what about as a first home?

**Hud3** · 23-06-2009, 12:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by grunzster

I don't own a house, so what about as a first home?

Here's what the IRS says about it in their rules (excerpt)...

Quote:

Qualified Home

For you to take a home mortgage interest deduction, your debt must be secured by a qualified home. This means your main home or your second home. A home includes a house, condominium, cooperative, mobile home, house trailer, boat, or similar property that has sleeping, cooking, and toilet facilities....

Main home. You can have only one main home at any one time. This is the home where you ordinarily live most of the time.
Second home. A second home is a home that you choose to treat as your second home.

Source: IRS Publication 936

BlueSovereign · 23-06-2009, 15:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hud3

When I recently renewed my T.L. Dallas insurance policy, one of the questions on the renewal questionnaire was, "Is this boat your full-time residence?" I can only assume that the policy premium would be affected one way or the other by the answer to that question, but I'm not sure how.

I can tell you how it will increase your insurance premium in NZ: It will increase it! ... I know that for fact!

Maren · 22-06-2009, 15:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by grunzster

I've always heard, from various different forums that if you have a loan on your boat, you don't need to tell the bank your living aboard...unless they have clause against liveaboards, in which case you should have found a different lender in the first place.

But that you should always tell your insurance, because if they find out, you could have all kinds of problems as severe as losing your insurance or being denied a claim.

This is job for TabbyCat!

Captain Bill · 22-06-2009, 15:49

You can definitely claim the boat as a second home if it has a head, cooking facilities, sleeping facilities, and Bathing facilities and the loan is secured by the boat. You can't take a second mortgage out on your residence and take this deduction. Turbo tax does not handle it well and tries to put it on the line for a mortgage with a 1099 and it needs to go on the next line. It is likely that your lender will not give you a 1099 because as mine put it " we have no way of telling if a boat qualifies as a second home" so they treat it as a consumer loan. I have just requested a written statement of interest from them every year, which the customer service department is happy to give me. This deduction seems to be a red flag with the IRS for an audit trigger. They sent me a bill for $12000 and change plus interest. I sent them a statement with copies of my USCG documentation (proving I am the registered owner of the boat), a copy of my mortgage agreement, and photographs of the required facilities. About a month later they sent me a letter stating that they were satisfied with the evidence I presented and that they considered the matter settled with no money due. Keep in mind that this is my personal experience, not legal tax advice. You should consult an accoutant or tax attorney.

1960cjj · 22-06-2009, 17:52

Quote:

Originally Posted by Captain Bill

This deduction seems to be a red flag with the IRS for an audit trigger. They sent me a bill for $12000 and change plus interest. I sent them a statement with copies ................................they were satisfied with the evidence I presented and that they considered the matter settled with no money due.

So with the IRS you are guilty until proven innocent.

Craig

grunzster · 23-06-2009, 12:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by Captain Bill

You can definitely claim the boat as a second home if it has a head, cooking facilities, sleeping facilities, and Bathing facilities and the loan is secured by the boat. You can't take a second mortgage out on your residence and take this deduction. Turbo tax does not handle it well and tries to put it on the line for a mortgage with a 1099 and it needs to go on the next line. It is likely that your lender will not give you a 1099 because as mine put it " we have no way of telling if a boat qualifies as a second home" so they treat it as a consumer loan. I have just requested a written statement of interest from them every year, which the customer service department is happy to give me. This deduction seems to be a red flag with the IRS for an audit trigger. They sent me a bill for $12000 and change plus interest. I sent them a statement with copies of my USCG documentation (proving I am the registered owner of the boat), a copy of my mortgage agreement, and photographs of the required facilities. About a month later they sent me a letter stating that they were satisfied with the evidence I presented and that they considered the matter settled with no money due. Keep in mind that this is my personal experience, not legal tax advice. You should consult an accoutant or tax attorney.

What if it's your primary residence, though? How exactly does that work?

I've always just been a renter, so I don't own a house. Been crashing at the parent's since my last lease ran out last November.

Captain Bill · 22-06-2009, 18:08

Absolutely, I wouldn't be surprised to have to do this every year. Last August they had just gotten around to 2006 tax year, this August I'm pretty much expecting to hear about 2007.

Chrisc · 22-06-2009, 20:48

When I renewed my insurance here in NZ I negotiated a reduction in the premium because I was a liveaboard. I argued that being permanently on board greatly reduced the risk of break-in and burglary, bad weather damage, degradation, ingress of water and just about anything else I could dream up. Happily, my broker agreed with me.

22-06-2009, 12:39	#1
grunzster Registered User Join Date: Nov 2008 Location: Highlands, NJ Boat: Gemini 105M, Grouchy Turtle Posts: 257	Claim Yourself as a Liveaboard? - & Tax Question I've always heard, from various different forums that if you have a loan on your boat, you don't need to tell the bank your living aboard...unless they have clause against liveaboards, in which case you should have found a different lender in the first place. But that you should always tell your insurance, because if they find out, you could have all kinds of problems as severe as losing your insurance or being denied a claim. Then on my trip North I ran into someone who gave me a completely different story. He basically told me that the insurance companies kind of define liveaboards as bums with nowhere else to go, and claiming youself as a live abaord would mean a huge increase in your premium, which I've never heard before. He went on to say if you're living aboard by choice, as in you have friends/family in the area where you can go or enough money to buy rent someplace on land, then technically you're not a liveaboard. Also that when you start cruising you should claim yourself as an extended cruiser, not a liveaboard, because that will also make a difference in how your insurance company charges you. Sounded like a bunch of semantics BS to me, also he seemed to really base this whole theory on FL, which in general really seems to have it out for boaters these day, but I'm not in FL. My policy costs about 1/3 what it would if I ws in FL, so even if it was to go up a little, I doubt it would be that much. So, is there any shred of truth to this, or should I be on the phone with my insurance ASAP? Also, I was thinking, even if what this guy said is true. The tiny little bit my insurance may go up, may be offset by potential tax breaks by claiming the boat as a primary residence...especially being that I have a mortgage on it. Which brings me to question #2. When tax time comes, for all you TurboTax users out there, do I claim the boat the same as a house? AKA: the screen where it asks "Any major life changes this year, for example bought a home?" do I click yes, and go through that whole process that same as if it was a house.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes	Rate This Thread
Switch to Linear Mode Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode	Rate This Thread:

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Insurance Co. Claim Payout?	bobfnbw	Dollars & Cents	15	16-10-2009 11:21
Puerto Rico Boat Tax Question	daysailj	Atlantic Ocean & the Caribbean	1	06-11-2008 12:13
Are Waeco's as good as they claim to be	rsn48	Plumbing Systems and Fixtures	12	18-06-2007 06:08
Cruiser from Vancouver, BC - question in Liveaboard section	HughP	Meets & Greets	2	20-11-2006 11:06
China Map Lays Claim To Americas	CaptainK	Pacific Ocean & the South China Sea	5	16-01-2006 11:41

22-06-2009, 13:23	#2
Cheechako Registered User Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Skagit City, WA Boat: Fellippi 32 Posts: 2,205	I would say nothing unless they ask for the info. I dont see why you are obligated to give info you are not asked for. Many will ask I imagine. On the other hand, dont lie either for sure. Interestingly, in the mid 80's when I sailed to Mexico from the Pac Northwest, the insurance company I was with offerred insurance that covered "inland waters and within 75 miles of the coast". Therefore I was insured all the way down the rough Pacific Coast (the "graveyard of the pacific") until I exited the US! This was standard cheap insurance like sold for ski boats etc... I'm sure that has changed! The insurance game seems to be very vague at times, I guess they figure they have more money for lawyers than the buyer does! My current auto insurance company asks for the anticipated driving mileage on each vehicle. For reasons I dont need to go into here, I have traded vehicles a lot in the last couple of years. In doing so, I have changed which cars I drive to work etc. I have received 3 different answers from them about when I can change the predicted mileage. Once they said only at renewal time (May every year), then at renewal time they said, only at the year anniversary of insuring that particular auto, (Both these times I wanted to reduce my predicted mileage), Once when I said I wanted to raise it, they did it right then! (more money for them) It's a real racket....

22-06-2009, 14:06	#3
grunzster Registered User Join Date: Nov 2008 Location: Highlands, NJ Boat: Gemini 105M, Grouchy Turtle Posts: 257	Well the bank made me sign a no charter affidavit, but not one for living aboard, and my insurance didn't ask anything about living aboard either. So as of now, I'm not lying to either, just not providing additional info that wasn't asked for. I never really thought of this before, but with a vessel of over a certain size, that has a galley, head, and berth...wouldn't they kind of assume that you're going to be living aboard at least part time? At least maybe weekends for example.

22-06-2009, 15:49	#11
Captain Bill Registered User Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: North Carolina Boat: Endeavourcat Sailcat 44, Spiraserpula Posts: 269	You can definitely claim the boat as a second home if it has a head, cooking facilities, sleeping facilities, and Bathing facilities and the loan is secured by the boat. You can't take a second mortgage out on your residence and take this deduction. Turbo tax does not handle it well and tries to put it on the line for a mortgage with a 1099 and it needs to go on the next line. It is likely that your lender will not give you a 1099 because as mine put it " we have no way of telling if a boat qualifies as a second home" so they treat it as a consumer loan. I have just requested a written statement of interest from them every year, which the customer service department is happy to give me. This deduction seems to be a red flag with the IRS for an audit trigger. They sent me a bill for $12000 and change plus interest. I sent them a statement with copies of my USCG documentation (proving I am the registered owner of the boat), a copy of my mortgage agreement, and photographs of the required facilities. About a month later they sent me a letter stating that they were satisfied with the evidence I presented and that they considered the matter settled with no money due. Keep in mind that this is my personal experience, not legal tax advice. You should consult an accoutant or tax attorney.

22-06-2009, 18:08	#14
Captain Bill Registered User Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: North Carolina Boat: Endeavourcat Sailcat 44, Spiraserpula Posts: 269	Absolutely, I wouldn't be surprised to have to do this every year. Last August they had just gotten around to 2006 tax year, this August I'm pretty much expecting to hear about 2007.

22-06-2009, 20:48	#15
Chrisc Registered User Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Tauranga, New Zealand Boat: Cav 39 yacht "Golden Girl" Posts: 85	When I renewed my insurance here in NZ I negotiated a reduction in the premium because I was a liveaboard. I argued that being permanently on board greatly reduced the risk of break-in and burglary, bad weather damage, degradation, ingress of water and just about anything else I could dream up. Happily, my broker agreed with me.