I will be in BVI for a week in late May and was wondering where the best dive spots are? We will be using a local dive shop and would gladly accept recommendations for that as well. We will probably only dive for a couple of days.
Dive BVI will know which dives are best, depending on visibility, swell direction, etc. I would go with their advice, since you can always snorkel some of the best spots by yourself, including the stern of the Rhone, the Chimney (Great Dog), and Monkey Point (Guana Island).
I 3rd the Dive BVI choice. We've dealt with them a number of times and they've always been top notch.
They'll know exactly where to take you. We wanted to do the Chikuzen one day but conditions weren't good for it. We did Wreck alley. Then we were going to do vanishing rock but conditions weren't so good so we did Thumb rock instead. Dives were both great!