Personally, I would think taking the route west of Eleuthera is a daysail route. Some of it is pretty skinny. A few thoughts:
cut - time this for slack water
. This can be a sleigh ride.
There are some places to stop - Hatchet bay, good all round protection. I'd only enter in daylight. Rock Sound - good protection. Shallow in spots.
You'll have to dodge lobster buoys. They were easy to see in daylight.
near entrance to rock sound, you'll also have to dodge some coral
heads. This was also easy in daylight.
I highly recommend getting the Explorer Charts
. All this is well documented.
Good luck, enjoy the trip.