Hard Dinghies

sjs · 12-02-2004, 06:54

Not sure many out there are still using hard dinghies anymore but I am considering the purchase of a Walker Bay 8 Classic. Does anyone have any opinions on this dinghy?

Interested in handling under oar, capacity, durability, handling under outboard and sailing ability, in that order, with the first three items of substantial import and the last item of very minor import.

Chuck Baier · 12-02-2004, 08:55

sjs, We cruised with a hard dinghy for about a month and then got a RIB. The hard dinghy beat up the hull, swamped with more than two people in it. Would not hold the weight of a suitable outboard for serious cruisers, was very heavy and awkward to store on deck. Impossible to dive or snorkel from, and filled with water anytime we towed it in any kind of chop. Other than that it was fine. Guess it depends on how you plan to use it. If only from the boat to shore and only in calm conditions then go for it. We have seen very very few long distance cruisers with hard dinghy's and for good reasons.

**Steve Rust** · 13-02-2004, 00:30

In a recent Cruising World they compared several hard dinghies. The Walker Bay seemed to compare well and it has an unbeatable price. I carry both a hard dinghy and an Achilles sport boat on my trimaran. I built the hard dinghy myself out of vacum bagged veneer, it is 11 feet and weighs about 80 lbs. It has a sailing rig (big plus) and gets the most use as I enjoy rowing. I very seldom tow it and then only for short distances. The sportboat is mainly used if we need or want to travel a greater distance or get somewhere fast. It spends alot of time stashed in it's bag in a wing locker. I don't usually feel the need to dash around in an outboard fueled rush all the time.

I think the biggest drawback of a RIB or sportboat with larger outboards is the theft problem. I know it is no fun to row a sportboat any distance if the motor fails. Never had a RIB so I don't know about how well they row.

undrsol · 13-02-2004, 05:51

check out portland pudgy's website- i found them doing a google search. Hard plastic dinghy like walker Bay but foam filled hull= great buoyancy and higher carrying capacity. Also comes with numerous compartment, sailing rig, etc and weighs 88 lbs. BTW I have no affiiation with them- just the latest toy I'm lusting after

Happy searching

sjs · 13-02-2004, 06:10

Yeah, it's the rowing thing that interests me most about a hard dinghy. Thanks guys for the input.

CSY Man · 13-02-2004, 08:01

Lived aboard for 3 yearts with a hard dink and loved it.
A Dyer Dhow, 9 feet with sailing rig and rudder.

USed it for water taxi as we were too young and boat poor to by an outboard....Just rowed and sailed....It was great.
That dink came with my boat, otherwise Icould not have been able to affrod it...They still make 'em and the price is over 3K meh thinks.
Easy to row, light enough to lift...Etc.

The Walker Bay dinks got good reports in "Practical Sailor" magazine...I would consider one if Iwas going for hard again.

Now I have an Avon Redcrest soft bottom....Good enough for my use...Which is to get moa, the wife and picnic/beer cooler in to the beach at some Bahamian Island...Or to snorke the reefs..
Soft bottom, very slow..4 knots with a 4 HP Evinrude...Still happy with the setup...Still thinking occasionally about that handsome Dyer Dhow I had 20 years ago....In my youth.....Hmm, time for a mid-life crises again....Last time I had one, bought a Harley and got a young girlfriend....This time...Hmm, cut loose and go sailing again...Aye, keep on dreaming..

Oops, off topic, sorry.....Go for either type of dink, they botk work, just 2 different animals.

Fox · 08-05-2004, 20:03

I know this is an old old thread, but you might find the following article helpful.

http://www.fattyknees.com/fatty_knees_goodoldboat.html

It's a review of four sailing dinghies, including the Walker 8.

(The formatting somehow got screwed up on the first paragraph, but the rest of the article is okay, so don't let that dissuade you)

12-02-2004, 06:54	#1
sjs Registered User Join Date: Jan 2004 Posts: 86	Hard Dinghies Not sure many out there are still using hard dinghies anymore but I am considering the purchase of a Walker Bay 8 Classic. Does anyone have any opinions on this dinghy? Interested in handling under oar, capacity, durability, handling under outboard and sailing ability, in that order, with the first three items of substantial import and the last item of very minor import.

12-02-2004, 08:55	#2
Chuck Baier Registered User Join Date: Mar 2003 Location: Where ever the boat is. Boat: Marine Trader 34 "Beach House" Posts: 1,719 Images: 54	sjs, We cruised with a hard dinghy for about a month and then got a RIB. The hard dinghy beat up the hull, swamped with more than two people in it. Would not hold the weight of a suitable outboard for serious cruisers, was very heavy and awkward to store on deck. Impossible to dive or snorkel from, and filled with water anytime we towed it in any kind of chop. Other than that it was fine. Guess it depends on how you plan to use it. If only from the boat to shore and only in calm conditions then go for it. We have seen very very few long distance cruisers with hard dinghy's and for good reasons. __________________ To boldly go!! Read about our past and current cruises, the boat, some projects and a whole lot more at Voyages of Sea Trek And Now Visit The New Boats Site At The Beach House

13-02-2004, 05:51	#4
undrsol Registered User Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: Boston, MA Boat: Brewer, Kaiulani 38, 41'LOA, "Kaiulani" Posts: 15 Images: 17	portland pudgy check out portland pudgy's website- i found them doing a google search. Hard plastic dinghy like walker Bay but foam filled hull= great buoyancy and higher carrying capacity. Also comes with numerous compartment, sailing rig, etc and weighs 88 lbs. BTW I have no affiiation with them- just the latest toy I'm lusting after Happy searching

13-02-2004, 08:01	#6
CSY Man Registered User Join Date: Aug 2003 Location: Ft. Lauderdale Boat: CSY 33 Cutter, "Rhapsody" Posts: 1,758 Images: 50	Lived aboard for 3 yearts with a hard dink and loved it. A Dyer Dhow, 9 feet with sailing rig and rudder. USed it for water taxi as we were too young and boat poor to by an outboard....Just rowed and sailed....It was great. That dink came with my boat, otherwise Icould not have been able to affrod it...They still make 'em and the price is over 3K meh thinks. Easy to row, light enough to lift...Etc. The Walker Bay dinks got good reports in "Practical Sailor" magazine...I would consider one if Iwas going for hard again. Now I have an Avon Redcrest soft bottom....Good enough for my use...Which is to get moa, the wife and picnic/beer cooler in to the beach at some Bahamian Island...Or to snorke the reefs.. Soft bottom, very slow..4 knots with a 4 HP Evinrude...Still happy with the setup...Still thinking occasionally about that handsome Dyer Dhow I had 20 years ago....In my youth.....Hmm, time for a mid-life crises again....Last time I had one, bought a Harley and got a young girlfriend....This time...Hmm, cut loose and go sailing again...Aye, keep on dreaming.. Oops, off topic, sorry.....Go for either type of dink, they botk work, just 2 different animals. Last edited by CSY Man; 13-02-2004 at 08:13.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes	Rate This Thread
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode	Rate This Thread:

13-02-2004, 00:30	#3
Steve Rust Moderator Site Helper Join Date: Sep 2003 Location: Minneapolis MN Boat: Searunner 40 Trimaran, Siruis 22 mono, 16 foot MFG daysailor Posts: 509 Images: 82	In a recent Cruising World they compared several hard dinghies. The Walker Bay seemed to compare well and it has an unbeatable price. I carry both a hard dinghy and an Achilles sport boat on my trimaran. I built the hard dinghy myself out of vacum bagged veneer, it is 11 feet and weighs about 80 lbs. It has a sailing rig (big plus) and gets the most use as I enjoy rowing. I very seldom tow it and then only for short distances. The sportboat is mainly used if we need or want to travel a greater distance or get somewhere fast. It spends alot of time stashed in it's bag in a wing locker. I don't usually feel the need to dash around in an outboard fueled rush all the time. I think the biggest drawback of a RIB or sportboat with larger outboards is the theft problem. I know it is no fun to row a sportboat any distance if the motor fails. Never had a RIB so I don't know about how well they row.

13-02-2004, 06:10	#5
sjs Registered User Join Date: Jan 2004 Posts: 86	Yeah, it's the rowing thing that interests me most about a hard dinghy. Thanks guys for the input.

08-05-2004, 20:03	#7
Fox Registered User Join Date: May 2004 Location: Near Calgary Posts: 3	I know this is an old old thread, but you might find the following article helpful. http://www.fattyknees.com/fatty_knees_goodoldboat.html It's a review of four sailing dinghies, including the Walker 8. (The formatting somehow got screwed up on the first paragraph, but the rest of the article is okay, so don't let that dissuade you)

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Ghost Ships in Hurricane Marty???	bradbarrett	General Sailing Forum	8	09-10-2003 10:31
Hard Dodger	Skylark	Monohull Sailboats	5	19-05-2003 14:08