After getting many quotes I did end up going with Seaworthy, the price
was one of the best (not THE best, but close enough) and they cover the Bahamas to Turk Island in the policy. I'm waiting for the actual policy, but according to the broker they also cover 50% of a haulout during a named storm threat. Most of the others only covered out to 75 miles, which impacts even direct trips from Pensacola
(home port) to the Keys. On these planned sails
I certainly could just pull into Tampa to stay within the 75 mile limit and have a rest, but I want that to be MY decision, not my insurance provider's. I have found a couple marinas that don't require insurance, but I think not having basic liability insurance is taking too much of a risk (just mho).
Bringing Whish up from Tarpon Springs next weekend; looking forward to the trip.