If you can charter out of G Town Exuma, that would be pretty sweet in May. And if you never left the harbor, it would not feel like a waste. I'm sure you could cover some miles if you are an experienced skipper
I have only flown to GGT inter-island from NAS or FPO, but check the price
of flights; easy enough to get to, connecting in one of the above airports through Bahamasair, et alia.
If you charter out of E. Florida
, be prepared to cruise
. There's worse ways to spend your time, but not by much
Ok I'm biased, born on G. Bahama
would be great too, but only if you can go to Green turtle or some of the other Cays, and might have a little cold front action then, Tingum would know best.
Ok I know I'm Mr singlehander loner dude, but 12 people on a boat? Really? I'd plan ample opportunity for shore leave.
best of luck, have a blast.