Re: Need Help with BVIs or Bahamas
I'd have to third George Town. You can rent a Whaler and hit dozens of deserted beaches both along Stocking Island and Crab Cay. A great community there, too. For a place to stay, Club Peace & Plenty has been very good to me, and I'd call the bar at the Two Turtles my favorite bar on the planet.
I've gone in November several times, and March a couple of times. But there's never a bad time to be there as far as I'm concerned.
If you decide to go, make sure you find the deserted beaches on Stocking Island, down by the north end. Three private, gorgeous beaches you have to want to get to, but when you do, they are worth seeing.