The best one I took started in Puerto Rico
, then Dominican Republic
, St Martin
, St Thomas and back to P.R.
Second best was Galveston, cozumel, Grand Cayman, Jamaica
Both were Royal Carribean, which I prefer over Carnival.
The 24 hour buffet on Carinival is an excuse to get fat
I think its better to pick an island and stay awhile, I lived in Antigua
for a couple years, wish I could go back. Stayed on Grand Cayman for a week, and loved it very much.
Even better rent a boat and sail from island to island.
Best is own a boat and sail anywhere you want