Are you intending to use it on all the bands it supports?
You can get a decent 2m/70cm vertical omni for
cheap, but a 1/4 wave groundplane with a vertical for both those bands and 2 of the legs cut for 2m and 2 cut for 70cm up in the
rigging would be
cheap and probably better than most production verticals down at the
deck level. Those bands are really about antenna height.
Having said that, I intend to take a folding yagi for both of those bands as they are cheap and gain is gain. If you know the direction of the guy you want to talk to, and your omni isn't getting it done, a $70 collapsible can give you 5 times the
power instantly. Candles vs flashlights.
Now for the HF bands, things are really about size constraints. Most masts top out at what? 60ft? So that's just below 20m band. So from 20m up you could build tuned verticals (although I would probably just use tuned endfed antennas and a
halyard. (this is my plan)
I think most folks buy a vertical as long as they can get and add a tuner, but this just fools the
radio into thinking the antenna is a good match, it doesn't 'fix' the antenna. Tuned antennas are always best.
I'd consider a screwdriver also, just for the simplicity of band switching, but you said you didn't want a whip, and screwdrivers are basically motorized base-loaded whips.
73
stimp