From practical experience when cruising - no.
Our last boat came with a 90% self tacking blade headsail and a huge main. We got a symetrical spinnaker
for off the breeze running. This was in 2005. All cross cut and well built.
The blade headsail was super high & fast upwind in medium to strong winds, but as you'd imagine not the best reaching and frankly no good upwind in the light stuff.
So in 2006 we ordered a 200% mylar code 0 which was an increadible sail. It needed to be as it cost 10,000 euro. It gave us 7 knots boat speed upwind in 7 knots of true breeze. Perfect sail if the conditions were right or if you were racing
in light stuff with a big crew.
But it came on it's own facnor furler
and would not last a month with too much UV exposure. Meaning rigging
it took 30 minutes at least. Taking it down two up when the apparent breeze got close to 20 knots was a real PITA. And the sailbag to hold it took as much space as the spinnaker
So in 2007 we got a well built 120% genoa
which would still work upwind if furled to 100%. It was the answer to a lot of our needs. We reached like deamons, went quick upwind in light to medium, still stormed upwind in stronger stuff with it furled, and even off the breeze the genoa
poled out was almost only a knot
slower than the spinnaker. And a lot easier for two to handle.
A month in and the blade headsail went to the bin. I doubt we used the code 0 more than three hours over the following 3 years. And only used the spinnaker when racing
They say you learn by your mistakes
so hope others can learn from ours.
As a result of the above, I'd forget a pure light wind
sail and suggest a well cut furling
genoa with a foam luff would meet the needs, last longer, and save the cost and space consumed by multiple sails